Using Lightroom and then ACR and Photoshop on a another Computer

  • Thread starter Thread starter clarkdan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

clarkdan

Guest
Hi all,

I am new to this forum and posting this question for my son. His problem is how can he post process his photos at home (using Lightroom 2) as well as at school on the macs where they only use Photoshop and of course ACR? He stores all his photos on a portable external hard drive so moving them is not the question but rather how will the changes he makes in photoshop/ACR at school be recognized back in lightroom?

Just to clarify, If he was to import a shoot's pictures into lightroom one night and then take the ex HD to school and wanted to edit the photos how could he do this?

Sorry , we are both new to RAW and in a way it is all a bit confusing,

Thanks alot,

Danny
 
Danny, welcome to the forums.

I think he should be able to just save the metadata, ctrl-s, for the adjusted images. For raw types, this will create sidecar files of type .XMP, which will contain his adjustments. When opening the raws with PS, ACR should read and process those files. There are a couple of things you can do in Lr, that are not stored in the XMP, but they are fundamentally related to workflow and asset management. All of your actual image adjustments should be saved. The bonus here, is that if the raw files exist both at school, and at home, you will only have to transport the XMP files. Which are tiny (< 3'kB), when contrasted to the raws.

One of our gurus, Victoria, fundamentally does this for a living, though, let's see if she has any advice.
 
Thanks alot Brad, that should be easy enough for him. Just having to transfer the .xmp files is good but I don't think his allows that much storage on the servers. He was only worried that if he used lightroom like me then there would be no way of being able to edit his images at school as well.

Thanks again,
Danny
 
Yep, xmp's are the way to go. As Brad said, he'll write to xmp (ctrl-s) when he's finished in LR, go off to school with the files on the external drive (and you'll be able to see the xmp files next to the raw files), ACR should automatically read and write that xmp with any changes, and when he comes home, he can select those files in LR again and go to Metadata menu > Read Metadata from Files. Only thing to watch out for is the LR things that aren't stored in XMP - flags, collections, Develop history, virtual copies being the main ones.
 
Could he not also convert to DNG and carry the metadata in the file itself? This would remove the need for the sidecar files. If you work in DNG make sure you select 'automatically make changes into XMP' in the catalog settings.

Julian
 
Yes. The principle issue, in my point of view, being the file size. Presuming the raw files already exist at each end of the transaction, moving just the XMP adjustment data alone is economical with copy time and space. If the raw data needs to move as well, then either method will work equally well, I think, as Julian points out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top