The Perfect is the Enemy of the Good.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Replytoken

Senior Member
Lightroom Guru
Premium Classic Member
Premium Cloud Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
3,538
Location
Puget Sound
Lightroom Experience
Intermediate
Lightroom Version
Classic
While I am sure Ian and any other slightly OC LR users will sympathize with my problem, I am not sure if I am looking more for advice or encouragement. While I have been actively learning about and using LR, DAM techniques and RAW conversion since last fall, there is a big difference between knowing how to do something, and spending lots of time doing it.

I am working on pulling together images to have Sharedink.com print as a book that I would like to present as a belated birthday gift (and use to evaluate the quality of their books). The photos, which I have selected and cropped in LR, happen to be from a Nikon D4' and were taken in JPEG format (this was before I switched to primarily shoting in RAW and with a D3''). So, they have reduced range for editing since they are not RAW and are 8-bit files. But, that does not exempt them from adjustments before printing, and that is my problem. I have always had trouble making decisions when correcting color images, and this goes back to my days when I was a part-time printer in a photo lab! Now its a good thing that I did not quit my day job, but I need to get a wrap on this project, and I am not certain what is frustrating me more. My indecision, or LR's multitude of Develop tools.

I know there is no substitute for doing, but I just feel stuck in analysis paralysis. I want the images to look good, but I cannot seem to create any type of preset that would lead me towards project completion. Adjusting each image individually is also an option, but I keep spinning my wheels on that approach as well (too many choices). An editor (or coach) would probably be most helpful, but I do not know anybody locally who uses LR. Any thoughts or suggestions on how to tame the perfectionist within and get a wrap on this project before it becomes next year's early birthday gift?

--Ken
 
Break in down into little tasks.

First up, have you actually chosen the images for the book?
If not gather them all into a collection and open the first in Loupe view. It'll help if the standard previews are already created.
Hit Caps Lock then use P for Yes, U for maybe and X for no images. As you make picks, Lightroom will auto advance to the next image.
Then use the filter flags in the Filmstrip to show only Unflagged images and choose P or X for yes and no.
Finally for the picks, change the filter to show flagged images.
For similar images, use Compare to select the best and then unflag the other similars, unless you are doing a sequence of images.
Now you have your book selection. Save these into another collection.

Now go to the first image and examine the image and the histogram. Is it too dark/too light? Use the Quick Develop panel to get basic corrections done. Go through all the images this way. If you find an image that needs more, or special work, use a colour label to highlight it.
When done filter by that label and then go to develop to finish them off.
Export the finished files and make your book.
 
Use the Quick Develop panel to get basic corrections done. Go through all the images this way.
More good advice. I suffered the same problems of indecision and lack of consistency working my way through the Develop tools and ignored the Quick Develop panel until more recently. This has sped up my workflow by at least 5'% and probably more. I used to want to move every single slider in Develop to see its effect but have been impressed with QD that the pang of slider shifting has now gone and my results are cleaner.

Amongst the pros of using the QD panel is that you work on previews, so the full resolution image doesn't load like it does in Develop, making it faster to run through the images as you work on them. QD will give you consistent adjustments across the range, which you can then refine in Develop and apply finishing touches like noise reduction, refined sharpening, vignettes, crop, spot removal etc.
 
Ken, I have to add, that rarely do my major concerns with perceived flaws in my images attract the attention of non-photog viewers. I think to myself, "soft focus, lack of shadow detail, noise, crop, yada yada" My reviewers (non-pro clients, family, friends) see only the frozen moment in time, and say "good, nice, great, Wow!".

I've said it before, but I think it's worth repeating, "If the grass is green, the sky is blue, the horse is brown, and the eyes are in focus, it's good enough."

(Of course, I rarely listen to my own advice ... :) )
 
Break in down into little tasks.

First up, have you actually chosen the images for the book?
If not gather them all into a collection and open the first in Loupe view. It'll help if the standard previews are already created.
Hit Caps Lock then use P for Yes, U for maybe and X for no images. As you make picks, Lightroom will auto advance to the next image.
Then use the filter flags in the Filmstrip to show only Unflagged images and choose P or X for yes and no.
Finally for the picks, change the filter to show flagged images.
For similar images, use Compare to select the best and then unflag the other similars, unless you are doing a sequence of images.
Now you have your book selection. Save these into another collection.

Now go to the first image and examine the image and the histogram. Is it too dark/too light? Use the Quick Develop panel to get basic corrections done. Go through all the images this way. If you find an image that needs more, or special work, use a colour label to highlight it.
When done filter by that label and then go to develop to finish them off.
Export the finished files and make your book.

Hi Sean,

Thankfully, I have made it past image selection, cropping for the book format, and layout of the images. I normally bypass the Quick Develop command and go right into the Develop module and that is where I start to feel like Stasber used to feel about adjusting all of the sliders. I know that Kelby's book has a nice workflow to follow when adjusting images, but its not the order so much as making the decision.

These photos were taken indoors with flash, and every time I look at the histogram and try to lighten them up, I get very indecisive. As imported, they are somewhat warm with the background falling into the shadows. I can lighten them up, but the faces (my primary subjects) loose a bit of the warmth and the background becomes more clear. I can clearly see the differences, but its hard for me to say which is better.

While I have to agree with Brad's comments, I was hoping to use some good images since Shared Ink pretty much is a GIGO process if you are not careful. Nonetheless, I will try the Quick Develop commands, and will remember to keep breaking things down into small tasks.

Its just frustrating to hear of people who whip out their presets and quickly process large batches of images as though they were just tying their shoes. I know that presets can be helpful, but it seems like you really have to know what you are doing to get good quality adjustments from them, and I am not there yet!

Thanks for the suggestions and sympathy. I will keep you posted on how the book turns out in case anybody is interested in ordering from them.

--Ken
 
I do also like the idea of an editor/coach for this. This is one of those tasks that becomes much easier once you can see someone else do it, if that someone else can think out loud and communicate well. I don't know of anyone up there in your corner of the country, but if anyone here does...
 
This is one of those tasks that becomes much easier once you can see someone else do it, if that someone else can think out loud and communicate well.

This is exactly what I had in mind. For me, reading and posting can only go so far in helping me to better understand how I can approach this in a way that works for me. My MO is usually to ask a lot of questions up front, but then I am usually good to go from there. And, for me, color correction really seems to be one of those things best taught hands-on.

And if you can appreciate a good laugh, take a look at the comic strip Cathy from July 7 through today: http://www.gocomics.com/cathy/2''8/'7/'7 . I think, however, that Cathy and Irving are in need of more than an editor!

--Ken
 
This is one of those tasks that becomes much easier once you can see someone else do it, if that someone else can think out loud and communicate well.

Mark,

I know it would not be the same as face-to-face interaction, but do you think that a video might be a useful way to demonstrate color correction type edits?

--Ken
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top