panorama , does lightroom 6 incluse Content Aware Fill ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

mantra

Active Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2007
Messages
441
Lightroom Experience
Intermediate
Lightroom Version
No, Lightroom doesn't have content aware - or at least, it doesn't fill in gaps around the edges of the merged photo, if that's what you're thinking.
 
No, Lightroom does not have content-aware fill. I think that everyone would like to see that, but it's not that easy. The biggest problem is that any changes to the image will affect content-aware filled areas, so it would require a lot of recalculations that will slow down Lightroom. Photoshop does not have content-aware fill for smart objects either, possibly for the same reason.
 
No, not as such. Content aware fill is not part of ACR (which is at the heart of Lightroom), and so doesn't appear in Lightroom. It does have a Spot Removal brush which you can use to paint over small areas, but it works rather differently and is not as flexible or effective for large areas (in my opinion!).

Dave
 
No, Lightroom doesn't have content aware - or at least, it doesn't fill in gaps around the edges of the merged photo, if that's what you're thinking.
Hi
thanks Victoria

No, Lightroom does not have content-aware fill. I think that everyone would like to see that, but it's not that easy. The biggest problem is that any changes to the image will affect content-aware filled areas, so it would require a lot of recalculations that will slow down Lightroom. Photoshop does not have content-aware fill for smart objects either, possibly for the same reason.
thanks Johan
i see , instead seems very slow (i'm talking about content aware) in the spot removal ,selecting large areas of the image more sluggish then acr
i did not about
Photoshop does not have content-aware fill for smart objects either
No, not as such. Content aware fill is not part of ACR (which is at the heart of Lightroom), and so doesn't appear in Lightroom. It does have a Spot Removal brush which you can use to paint over small areas, but it works rather differently and is not as flexible or effective for large areas (in my opinion!).
Dave
hi Dave
you can use to paint over small areas,
in lightroom v6 , i can paint not only on small areas , but look
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drRtouc30w0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZJkhGDPfWw

thanks Dave
 
Last edited:
I think content aware fill is one of the things that should be left on the other side of the Ps/Lr divide. I see no reason to make Lr into Ps. Adding that feature would essentially require Lr to become a graphics art program, since it requires that there be a blank canvas upon which your image is laid. And then on to layers, etc.

And conceptually you are painting, not retouching, not editing. I see that as fundamentally different. Yeah, at times adding a cm3 of blue would be nice, but they've gotta draw the line (or fill in the gap) somewhere.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top