• Welcome to the Lightroom Queen Forums! We're a friendly bunch, so please feel free to register and join in the conversation. If you're not familiar with forums, you'll find step by step instructions on how to post your first thread under Help at the bottom of the page. You're also welcome to download our free Lightroom Quick Start eBooks and explore our other FAQ resources.
  • Stop struggling with Lightroom! There's no need to spend hours hunting for the answers to your Lightroom Classic questions. All the information you need is in Adobe Lightroom Classic - The Missing FAQ!

    To help you get started, there's a series of easy tutorials to guide you through a simple workflow. As you grow in confidence, the book switches to a conversational FAQ format, so you can quickly find answers to advanced questions. And better still, the eBooks are updated for every release, so it's always up to date.
  • 10 November 2026 It's Lightroom update time again. There are some minor features, as well as bug fixes, new cameras and lenses.
    See What’s New in Lightroom Classic 16.0, Mobile & Desktop (November 2026)?

Newbie to Lightroom, trying to move from Aperture

Status
Not open for further replies.

VictoriaJZ

Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2022
Messages
72
Location
Des Moines, Iowa
Lightroom Experience
Beginner
Lightroom Version
Classic
Lightroom Version Number
4.4 Classic
Operating System
I am on Mojave on my iMac and want to convert/migrate my Aplibraries to Lightroom [Classic] . On Mojave, the latest version of LR is 4 -- Apparently in Lightroom ver. 5+ there is some sort of plug in converter, but Lightroom 4 is needed to work on Mojave apparently [every time I try to install LR onto my Mojave machine it tells me I need an older version and apparently it's ver. 4 which is the one for Mojave. So the 'easy' plugin converter is not available, that I know of. -- I know/suppose I can do the migration the painful way but I was hoping there was some sort of plugin or converter which would relatively easily take the Aplibraries and move them into LR. Any ideas or suggestions?
 
I am on Mojave on my iMac and want to convert/migrate my Aplibraries to Lightroom [Classic] . On Mojave, the latest version of LR is 4 -- Apparently in Lightroom ver. 5+ there is some sort of plug in converter, but Lightroom 4 is needed to work on Mojave apparently [every time I try to install LR onto my Mojave machine it tells me I need an older version and apparently it's ver. 4 which is the one for Mojave. So the 'easy' plugin converter is not available, that I know of. -- I know/suppose I can do the migration the painful way but I was hoping there was some sort of plugin or converter which would relatively easily take the Aplibraries and move them into LR. Any ideas or suggestions?
I think you are getting mixed up with the Lightroom version naming. There are currently 2 different versions of "Lightroom", one called Lightroom Classic (which you seem to think you want) and which is currently at version 11.3.1. The other is called simply "Lightroom", and is the cloud-centric version and is currently at version 5.3.

If you intend to stay on Mojave, you can install Lightroom Classic version 10.4, or Lightroom version 4.4. The link that Johan provided appears to work in Lightroom Classic, so if Classic is the version you want to install do make sure you choose the correct product.
 
Thank you = am looking into Avalanche so thanks for that link == I do NOT want to stay on Mojave but have had to as long as I have used Aperture [and really love it, but do need to get serious] - the problem is the naming of Lightroom, which confuses me so thanks for the clarification on that = LRClassic 5 won't install on Mojave machine = Aperture works on Mojave machine and can migrate to LR4.4 - I tried to find LRClassic- I prefer to have my apps on my machines and not in the cloud = but apparently that's not possible. == the main benefit to me of Aperture has been the DAM properties and bulk editing = and my understanding is that in that respect LR might be akin to that == thus am trying to migrate as painlessly as possible to LR from Aperture but need to do it on a Mojave machine [iMac] for now.
 
Thank you = am looking into Avalanche so thanks for that link == I do NOT want to stay on Mojave but have had to as long as I have used Aperture [and really love it, but do need to get serious] - the problem is the naming of Lightroom, which confuses me so thanks for the clarification on that = LRClassic 5 won't install on Mojave machine = Aperture works on Mojave machine and can migrate to LR4.4 - I tried to find LRClassic- I prefer to have my apps on my machines and not in the cloud = but apparently that's not possible. == the main benefit to me of Aperture has been the DAM properties and bulk editing = and my understanding is that in that respect LR might be akin to that == thus am trying to migrate as painlessly as possible to LR from Aperture but need to do it on a Mojave machine [iMac] for now.

There is no reason to stay on Mojave. Upgrade the OS to the latest version of MacOS that your hardware supports. If your hardware is capable of running Monterey, then start by upgrading there. All you need for Aperture migration is the Library file. There are processes in Lightroom and Lightroom Classic to migrate your Aperture Library file and image files to the latest version of Lr or LrC.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
LRClassic 5 won't install on Mojave machine = Aperture works on Mojave machine and can migrate to LR4.4 - I tried to find LRClassic- I prefer to have my apps on my machines and not in the cloud = but apparently that's not possible.
There is NO LRClassic 5. Lightroom was originally introduced around 2007 with a new version increase typically every two years. By 2017 it was up to version 6 with version 7 about to be released. At that point Adobe threw everyone a huge curve ball and decided to change the name from Lightroom (version 7) to Lightroom Classic (version 7). That was OK, but at the same time they introduced a new desktop app which is cloud -centric (which means that the images are stored in the cloud....though all the apps are still installed on the local system) and called it Lightroom. Confusion has reigned ever since.

At the time that the Aperture plug-in was introduced, it may well have been around the original Lightroom 4.4 version....but that's pre-historic now, you really do not want that. You need either Lightroom Classic (current version is 11.3, but that can't be installed on Mojave, so 10.4 would have to be installed), or you need the cloud-centric Lightroom (current version is 5.3, but that can't be installed on Mojave, so 4.4 would have to be installed).
You say you can't find Lightroom Classic, where are you looking? All current Adobe apps are installed and managed via the Creative Cloud Desktop app, which you need to download and install from the Adobe web-site....but before doing that you will need to take out an Adobe subscription. There are various plans available, but first you need to decide which version of Lightroom you want to use. See this comparison: https://www.lightroomqueen.com/lightroom-cc-vs-classic-features/
 
There is no reason to stay on Mojave. Upgrade the OS to the latest version of MacOS that your hardware supports. If your hardware is capable of running Monterey, then start by upgrading there. All you need for Aperture migration is the Library file. There are processes in Lightroom and Lightroom Classic to migrate your Aperture Library file and image files to the latest version of Lr or LrC.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
There IS a reason to stay on Mojave until I can convert and move my ApLibraries over == maybe I don’t understand == if I upgraded my OS to Monterey or whatever can Avalanache or some other method open and work with my ApLibraries without them being able to be opened and run in Mojave? That might be my misunderstanding = if I don’t need to have the ApLibraries openable that resolves the problem I think == that was my conundrum
 
There is NO LRClassic 5. Lightroom was originally introduced around 2007 with a new version increase typically every two years. By 2017 it was up to version 6 with version 7 about to be released. At that point Adobe threw everyone a huge curve ball and decided to change the name from Lightroom (version 7) to Lightroom Classic (version 7). That was OK, but at the same time they introduced a new desktop app which is cloud -centric (which means that the images are stored in the cloud....though all the apps are still installed on the local system) and called it Lightroom. Confusion has reigned ever since.

At the time that the Aperture plug-in was introduced, it may well have been around the original Lightroom 4.4 version....but that's pre-historic now, you really do not want that. You need either Lightroom Classic (current version is 11.3, but that can't be installed on Mojave, so 10.4 would have to be installed), or you need the cloud-centric Lightroom (current version is 5.3, but that can't be installed on Mojave, so 4.4 would have to be installed).
You say you can't find Lightroom Classic, where are you looking? All current Adobe apps are installed and managed via the Creative Cloud Desktop app, which you need to download and install from the Adobe web-site....but before doing that you will need to take out an Adobe subscription. There are various plans available, but first you need to decide which version of Lightroom you want to use. See this comparison: https://www.lightroomqueen.com/lightroom-cc-vs-classic-features/
Thank you for the explanation. I’ll look into all this and get whatever is needed. I really dont want cloud based LR but maybe I misunderstood the options = appreciate the link
 
I have not tried it myself, but this seems to be the best solution: https://cyme.io/avalanche-photo-conversion/
To build on this, I've tried Avalanche with small sample catalogs and helped several others use Avalanche satisfactorily with large catalogs. Many people have tried to use the built-in Aperture/iPhoto Importer Plug-in, and it's a poorly implemented disaster -- it slows down to a glacial crawl after several thousand photos, it sometimes hangs or terminates prematurely with no error messages, and it sometimes mangles metadata.
 
There IS a reason to stay on Mojave until I can convert and move my ApLibraries over == maybe I don’t understand == if I upgraded my OS to Monterey or whatever can Avalanache or some other method open and work with my ApLibraries without them being able to be opened and run in Mojave? That might be my misunderstanding = if I don’t need to have the ApLibraries openable that resolves the problem I think == that was my conundrum

Yes, I don’t think you understand. Lightroom or Lightroom Classic only needs the Aperture Library FILE (not the app) And you don’t really need Avalanche since the Adobe apps have an Apple migration function included.

The recommendation to use Avalanche comes mainly from those than did not find the Adobe migration function to be meet their needs. Also Lightroom has a migration tool for Aperture and the current Apple Photos app and not the discontinued iPhoto app. OTOH LrC has a migration option for Aperture and iPhoto but not the current Photos app.

Personally, if I were at your stage, I would install the latest MacOS that my Mac can run, and the latest version of LrC, convert my Aperture Library to a Lightroom Classic Catalog using the migration tool included with LrC. Only if I were not happy with the LrC migration process result would I look into repeating the migration to a new catalog using Avalanche.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
There is an important reason why Avalanche was created, and that is more than to avoid having to use the error-prone built-in Lightroom plugin that seems to cause problems for almost anyone who uses it on a larger library. That reason is that Avalange uses artificial intelligence to convert the Aperture edits to Lightroom edits. The built-in plugin does not do that, so migrating from Aperture to Lightroom using the plugin makes you lose all the editing work you ever did in Aperture. The only option you have with the plugin is to import 1:1 Aperture previews as well, so you have at least a jpeg version with your Aperture edits applied to them next to the unedited raw file, but that is of course a far cry from having your non-destructive Aperture edits ‘translated’ into non-destructive Lightroom edits.
 
There is an important reason why Avalanche was created, and that is more than to avoid having to use the error-prone built-in Lightroom plugin that seems to cause problems for almost anyone who uses it on a larger library. That reason is that Avalange uses artificial intelligence to convert the Aperture edits to Lightroom edits. The built-in plugin does not do that, so migrating from Aperture to Lightroom using the plugin makes you lose all the editing work you ever did in Aperture. The only option you have with the plugin is to import 1:1 Aperture previews as well, so you have at least a jpeg version with your Aperture edits applied to them next to the unedited raw file, but that is of course a far cry from having your non-destructive Aperture edits ‘translated’ into non-destructive Lightroom edits.
YMMV. When the migration first was introduced, I used it twice. Once with Aperture and once with iPhoto. I did not have any problems understanding the directions and the results were fine for my purposes. I did not find it error prone. Admittedly, the App Libraries were small as I never use Aperture as a primary DAM and iPhoto was used primarily for phone photos.
It is for this reason that I recommend using Avalanche only is the built in Migration process fails.

By your own admission, you recommended Avalanche without trying it yourself. I could only recommend it based upon others that have purchased and used it successfully. I would certainly want to use the free Adobe migration before spending $60USD on a product that I would only use one time.
 
I don’t think I disagreed with you in any of my replies. Of course it makes sense to try a free option first. I just added some information I felt you left out. Depending on how many Aperture edit hours one has, that $60 could be well spent. Do you ever go to a restaurant and spend $60 on a meal? That is once only too…
 
OK just to double check before I jump off the cliff, so to speak == whether with LR or Avalanche I do NOT need Aperture3.6 app to actually run because it's the libraries which are being converted - silly me for not figuring that out. Honestly, then, what I need/want is something which will streamline the migration process and retain as much of the work as possible == I don't maintain a huge Aplibrary = over the years I have found it more useful to have topic-focused libraries...so the issue is what process is the most efficient and least destructive and painful. And for $60 [after I've tested it a bit] and skipping one might out might be worth it. Now to work on organizing my methods and thoughts. Again, thanks.
 
OK just to double check before I jump off the cliff, so to speak == whether with LR or Avalanche I do NOT need Aperture3.6 app to actually run because it's the libraries which are being converted - silly me for not figuring that out. Honestly, then, what I need/want is something which will streamline the migration process and retain as much of the work as possible == I don't maintain a huge Aplibrary = over the years I have found it more useful to have topic-focused libraries...so the issue is what process is the most efficient and least destructive and painful. And for $60 [after I've tested it a bit] and skipping one might out might be worth it. Now to work on organizing my methods and thoughts. Again, thanks.

Correct. You do not need Aperture 3.6, just the Aperture Library. If you have more than one library, you will need to run the migration off each Library.

The Steps are as follows:
1. Upgrade your MacOS to the latest version that your hardware permits. Hopefully this is Monterrey.
2. Purchase an Adobe Photography plan subscription. This will include both Lightroom Classic and Lightroom. You will only need to initially install Lightroom Classic since you want to keep your master image files and catalog locally and not in the Adobe Cloud.
3. On install, a new empty Lightroom Catalog will be created. Use this to Migrate your Aperture Library into. As Johan and I recommends, start with the Adobe included Aperture migration process. If you have more than one library pick the largest one.
4. The Migration will import the original unedited image files. And an option to also migrate the Aperture edited derivatives.
5. If the Adobe migration process is successful to your satisfaction And you have other Libraries, the continue to migrate those.
6. If you are not satisfies with the results of the Lightroom Classic migration process, Create a new empty Catalog and down Load the Avalanche free trial. It may only permit you to migrate a few of the Aperture Library images as a test. If that is the case, then purchase the Avalanche app and repeat using the full Aperture library and a new empty Lightroom Catalog.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Correct. You do not need Aperture 3.6, just the Aperture Library. If you have more than one library, you will need to run the migration off each Library.

The Steps are as follows:
1. Upgrade your MacOS to the latest version that your hardware permits. Hopefully this is Monterrey.
2. Purchase an Adobe Photography plan subscription. This will include both Lightroom Classic and Lightroom. You will only need to initially install Lightroom Classic since you want to keep your master image files and catalog locally and not in the Adobe Cloud.
3. On install, a new empty Lightroom Catalog will be created. Use this to Migrate your Aperture Library into. As Johan and I recommends, start with the Adobe included Aperture migration process. If you have more than one library pick the largest one.
4. The Migration will import the original unedited image files. And an option to also migrate the Aperture edited derivatives.
5. If the Adobe migration process is successful to your satisfaction And you have other Libraries, the continue to migrate those.
6. If you are not satisfies with the results of the Lightroom Classic migration process, Create a new empty Catalog and down Load the Avalanche free trial. It may only permit you to migrate a few of the Aperture Library images as a test. If that is the case, then purchase the Avalanche app and repeat using the full Aperture library and a new empty Lightroom Catalog.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
To everyone, thank you so much for holding my hand....now to get busy !! Your help is much appreciated.
 
One quick followup Q -- elsewhere was suggested that before the Adobe internal migration plug in use, one should update the previews to be 100% [assuming space is available] and then do the plug in import == I would like to preserve as much as I can in the edited items [ie keywords, the edits made etc] = would that be the thing to do = does LR then bring in both the RAW file and it's edited Version 2? And the Ver. 2 would then be in the main part preserved? Again, thanks for your patience with my Q.
 
One quick followup Q -- elsewhere was suggested that before the Adobe internal migration plug in use, one should update the previews to be 100% [assuming space is available] and then do the plug in import == I would like to preserve as much as I can in the edited items [ie keywords, the edits made etc] = would that be the thing to do = does LR then bring in both the RAW file and it's edited Version 2? And the Ver. 2 would then be in the main part preserved? Again, thanks for your patience with my Q.

What you are calling 100% Previews is probably an Aperture edited version of what I defined as a derivative where a JPEG is produced at 100% with all of the Aperture Edit Adjustments. The Migration process then will import 2 files into Lightroom Classic. One file being the original unedited that was imported into Aperture. The other being a fully aperture edited JPEG.

That being the case, in my instructions above, I would prepend a NEW first step to create these Aperture 100% previews so that they will be available when the migration takes place.

Things like Keywords, Titles and other metadata will be migrated from the Aperture Library file into the Lightroom Classic Catalog and assigned to the images associated with them in Aperture.

Since the Aperture Edit processes do not translate to the Lightroom Edit processes. The only way to preserve them is by importing the derivative (100% preview) file.

You brought up a very good point and I am glad you did. I haven’t migrated Apple Libraries in several years and not aware of the inner working of Aperture.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
What you are calling 100% Previews is probably an Aperture edited version of what I defined as a derivative where a JPEG is produced at 100% with all of the Aperture Edit Adjustments. The Migration process then will import 2 files into Lightroom Classic. One file being the original unedited that was imported into Aperture. The other being a fully aperture edited JPEG.
Aperture 100% previews are the same as Lightroom Classic 1:1 previews, and just like in Lightroom Classic they are generated separately. Aperture does not even generate them when you zoom into the image however, because if I remember correctly Aperture does not have a 100% view option. Instead it has a loup tool, that you hold over the image. That means that only a small portion is viewed at 100%, so Aperture does not have to render a complete 1:1 preview for that. The 100% previews are used for interaction between Aperture and other apps, and must be generated specificly by the user for that purpose.
 
…The 100% previews are used for interaction between Aperture and other apps, and must be generated specificly by the user for that purpose.
Based upon the OPs request to preserve the Aperture Edits, I am thinking that these previews are needed to create derivative JPEGs to be included in the migration.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Based upon the OPs request to preserve the Aperture Edits, I am thinking that these previews are needed to create derivative JPEGs to be included in the migration.
Correct, they are needed. They are the derivative JPEGs that the plugin imports if you ask it to do that. The plugin cannot create derivative images that include Aperture edits, only Aperture itself can do that. That is why you’ll have to use Aperture to create 100% previews before you can use the Lightroom plugin to import them too.
 
First thanks to everyone - second, I'm on my iMac running Mojave with LR [I don't think it's classic = it's ver. 4.4, the only one which will work on the Mojave machine] - I'm going thru the aplibraries and redoing the previews to be 100% - and it's going okay but then I can't do the migration to LR with the plug in being used since that is something for ver. 5-- I did the preview updating in Aperture but when I tried to open an aplibrary in LR it wouldn't let me - "No images that can be imported were found in the selected source" - I tried several aplibraries and get that message = I can't move from Mojave on the iMac because it's the iMac that I'm using to convert/upgrade the Aplibraries == I do have a newer MBPro with Monterray but not with enough space to hold the imported/converted libraries into LRC - and the LR4.4 on my iMac is putting pics in the cloud, which I don't want....
 
I get the impression that you confuse two versions of Lightroom. The last version of Lightroom Classic that runs on MacOS Mojave is Lightroom Classic 10. There is a new and different app that is simply called ‘Lightroom’, which is at version 5.3 right now. The latest version of that app for MacOS Mojave may indeed be version 4.4, but that Lightroom can’t import an Aperture library at all and does not support plugins. If you want to import an Aperture library you need Lightroom Classic. https://www.adobe.com/products/photoshop-lightroom-classic/lightroom-cc-vs-lightroom-classic.html
 
Your impression is correct = I could not find/get/download LRC 10 -- I do have LR on my Monterey MBP - the conundrum is that I can't convert the previews in Mojave/Aperture and on the same machine then migrate the library to LRC - I'm now copying over a small Aplibrary to my Monterey MBP to see if it works okay == I may well want to get Avalanche just to get things accomplished == thanks for the help = I know there is a difference, but the issue is Adobe won't let me download LRC10 [as far as I know = I've tried].
 
but the issue is Adobe won't let me download LRC10 [as far as I know = I've tried].
It should do. Open the Creative Cloud Desktop app, click on the All Apps tab then find Lightroom Classic in the list of apps that can be installed. To the right of the "Install" button will be a tri-dot icon and clicking on that should give you an "Other Versions" button in a pop-up. Click on that and you should see a list of all the previous versions back to 10.0, you want the 10.4 version so click on the Install button for that specific version.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top