New Macs - Mac Mini or Mac Studio for Lightroom Classic

bobfreephotography

New Member
Premium Classic Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2020
Messages
4
LRc user. Time for a new computer. Was just about to pull the trigger on a new Mac and they announced the new versions. Now I'm wondering what people would recommend given these two configurations are the same price:

Mac Mini M5 Pro 18-Core Chip with 48 GB RAM 20-Core GPU | 16-Core Neural Engine
Mac Studio M5 Max with 36GB RAM 32-Core GPU | 16-Core Neural Engine

I occasionally shell out to Photoshop and used to use Topaz but it quit working on my older PC so I may be done with it. Also considering trying DXO Pure RAW again once I have a better computer but predominantly heavy LRc use. I do use AI Denoise and the masking panel a lot. I'm told that favors GPU performance over RAM.

Thanks

Bob
 
Both are very good configurations for probably most Lightroom Classic Mac users. My last two Macs have 32GB and 36GB of Unified Memory which have usually been more than enough for Lightroom Classic. I don’t think going to 48GB Unified Memory would make much difference unless you often edit very large layered files in Photoshop.

For Denoise, both have the same 16-Core Neural Engine.
For Denoise and other AI-powered features, the Mac Studio might be noticeably faster because it has a third more GPU cores. This will especially show up when processing large batches, like bulk updating AI settings, bulk preview generation, and bulk exporting because those features are all GPU-accelerated. But the performance of the Mac mini M5 Pro 20-core GPU will still be better than most Macs ever made .
 
Both are very good configurations for probably most Lightroom Classic Mac users. My last two Macs have 32GB and 36GB of Unified Memory which have usually been more than enough for Lightroom Classic. I don’t think going to 48GB Unified Memory would make much difference unless you often edit very large layered files in Photoshop.

For Denoise, both have the same 16-Core Neural Engine.
For Denoise and other AI-powered features, the Mac Studio might be noticeably faster because it has a third more GPU cores. This will especially show up when processing large batches, like bulk updating AI settings, bulk preview generation, and bulk exporting because those features are all GPU-accelerated. But the performance of the Mac mini M5 Pro 20-core GPU will still be better than most Macs ever made .
Thank you very much for the detailed reply. I appreciate it.
 
The new M6 Mini (non-pro) performs even better than the M5 Max for AI related tasks in LRC. The is due to M6 Neural Engine having a total of 32 cores, compared to 16 cores in all M1-M5 Macs. This is a huge jump in performance for these tasks.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jnGwzqr5HE

1790709333816.png


1790709376284.png
 
Depends on what you needs are. I'm a hobby shooter and don't batch Denoise AI. Last year I upgraded to a plain Mac Mini M4, 32GB. About 6 months ago Adobe re-enabled the Neural Engine. The time for Denoise AI dropped from about 40 seconds to 13. My MB Air M3, 24GB dropped from about 45 seconds to 15.

Both those Denoise times are good enough for me. Everything else is fast. I've done 75 + edits using LrC and not even a hiccup. So you won't go wrong with either and Denoise times are seconds apart according to those charts. I would have said that even without seeing those charts. Seems like the M6 chip wins. If you are not mass batch editing you will hardly notice a difference.
 
I was in the same situation, my office mac was an M1 mac mini with 16g ram, it worked fine, but was slowing up with each iteration of LRc and OS. We always buy a mac to last for at least 5 - 6 years, so we tend to go over the top in spec. Yes our other office mac is good (m4pro) but decided to go M5Max with 64g ram. It is basically a tank on steroids crazy fast on everything. But maybe the most interesting use is a local Ai , it can run huge models be that for code or business help, looking at seo or code errors on our website. Free to run and private

Its expensive and im still getting to grips with it in terms of set up and maxing performance with external drives (NAS and NVMe ) and so on but i have over 300 shoots a year and any time saved is worth it.

Both macs are really good, and you wont have an issue with either but perhaps the most future proof is the m5max
 
Bought a Mac Mini M2 16GB 3 years ago Lightroom CC runs fine for me but I don't use the denoise option I use DXO 6. Russ.
 
Bought a Mac Mini M2 16GB 3 years ago Lightroom CC runs fine for me but I don't use the denoise option I use DXO 6. Russ.
LrC needs 12GB. If you add PS it's 16GB. Its also about how many cores your system has. My old MB Air M1, 16GB Denoise AI dropped from 80 seconds to 20. LrC editing was smooth.
 
Also need to upgrade from 2020 iMac. Looking at mini, for both LR and PS, the M6 is better than M5 Pro?
 
Also need to upgrade from 2020 iMac. Looking at mini, for both LR and PS, the M6 is better than M5 Pro?
You will want to opt for the chip with the most CPU, GPU Cores. In decreasing order of performance:

M5Ultra, M5 Max, M5 Pro, M6
1793743005797.png
 
Back
Top