Metadata not saving to some JPGs (suspect: Red Eye)

  • Thread starter Thread starter blitzcraig
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

blitzcraig

Guest
Hey!

I've spent hours, meticulously adding keywords to about 2''' JPG images (this was before I got into RAW files). I realised that I hadn't saved the keyword metadata to the actual files, so I did a (Mac) CMD A, CMD S to select all and then save them.

This worked for almost every image, but failed for about 5' images. The only thing these images have in common that is unique to them is that they all had Red Eye adjustments using Lightroom's Red Eye tool -- none of the 'succesful' images had the red eye process.

Does anyone know how I can save the metadata info to these files? I've tried individually selecting them and hitting CMD S... Lightroom thinks about it (the down arrow turns into a 2-way arrow) then it gives up without explanation (it reverts to a down arrow).

Is this a bug, or am I doing something wrong?

Any help would be appreciated!

Cheers,

Craig.
 
Craig,

Hmmm, another new one on me. Welcome to LR Forums.

What tool are you using to determine whether the keywords are actually written or not?
At this point, it definitely sounds like a bug.
 
Hey, Brad! Thanks for the welcome!

I've only worked in Lightroom. I had set up the Grid View in Lightroom to display 'Unsaved Metadata'. Before I saved the changes, each image displayed the down arrow, indicating that 'metadata file needs to be updated'. After I did a Select All, then a CMD S to save, all the icons switched to the 2-way arrow to indicate the process was under way. But each image that had undergone a Red Eye adjustment reverted to the down arrow -- the metadata still needs to be updated.

I've only checked this info in Lightroom, I don't think I have any other programs that can read metadata.

Thanks for the quick reply!

Craig.
 
There's always been a bit of goofiness with some of that update metadata logic, (currently very strange in 2.'), so it's possible it's being written, and the bug is that LR is not indicating that. (i.e. the bug is in the tracking, and not the writing.)

I'm going to yield to a Mac guru who can tell us how to verify the metadata status. (I've got some suggestions for Windows, but ....).

The problem is, we need to look at your 'original' image files, anything you do to export images for us to 'snoop' will probably fix the metadata issue during export.
 
Thanks, Brad -- it'll be good to see if the data is possibly being saved but not updated in Grid View, as you say. Forgive my naivety, but would you like me to upload one of the files in question to the forum, and if so, how? I'm happy for a 'snoop' into the file -- the 'non-updated metadata' icon on all these files is making me nervous!

Thanks!

Craig
 
Let me make sure I'm correct first. LR 1.4.1 on Mac.

1) You're working with JPG files.
2) You did the ctrl-S thing to save the metadata, keywords and such.

Unfortunately, there's a size limit on posting JPG files here on the forum, aroun 25'kB, so that you original images are likely way too big. But, if you downsize them thru the export module, that's likely to fix the metadata problem, because metadata is rewritten at the export stage, (if you're set up to save metadata), or blanked out (if you aren't).

One thing you could do, is send me a file personally, either: directly to my email, if it's under 4-5 MBs, or via yousendit.com, if it's larger than that.

It would need to be an exact copy of one of the original jpg image files that you believe are not being updated metadata wise.

purple dot umbrella at verizon dot net will do fine for either method.

In the meantime, just out of curiosity, what is the status of the settings highlighted in the screen cap below?
 
Hey, Brad!

Thanks again for all your help and time with this issue, it's greatly appreciated!

Yep, I'm running Lightroom 1.4.1 on a Mac, and the files in question are all JPG files.

I sent you one of the files in question. This is right from the Finder/Explorer, so isn't affected by Lightroom (I don't think). The red eye issue is still visible. I took this into Lightroom a while back, performed a Red Eye correction, and then later tried to save the metadata to the file, and it wouldn't work.

After updating the metadata in most of my images last night, I then AFTERWARDS turned on 'Automatically write changes into XMP' (this was unchecked while I was having the problems). I'm *fairly* sure the entry above it 'Include Develop settings...' was checked the whole time (but not 1''% sure!)

With all those settings in place, I thought I'd give it one more go this morning, clicked on the attached image and hit CMD S to save the settings. The metadata icon went from the down arrow to the 2-way arrow as before, but then kept jumping back and forth between the two icons... it's stuck in a loop! I shut down Lightroom and opened it up again, and the loop continues.

Curioser and curioser!
 
Craig sent me the file, and it seems that his metadata was writing, so I'm not sure what was going on. I'm replying to Craig offline, but if anybody's interested in seeing the details, let me know, and I'll post my reply.
 
Thanks again for your time and effort, Brad! Glad to know the info is all still there, regardless of LR refusing to give up the icon. :)
 
One thing you could try Craig - select all, and actually click on the metadata icon instead of using ctrl-s. I know it's weird, but it's been known to solve icon issues.
 
Hey, Victoria!

I just tried what you suggested, but no go. Those icons are stuck fast! Thanks for the suggestion!

Craig.
 
One final thing you could try - select them, hit a + button in the Quick Develop, write to xmp, hit the opposite button in Quick Develop to undo the change, and write again. It forces LR to think it has to refresh. That's my last guess for tonight!
 
Thanks again, Victoria, but still no luck. Lightroom thinks about it, then reverts to the 'down arrow' icon.

It's frustrating, too, as I can't have "Automatically write changes into XMP" switched on, as Lightroom gets stuck in a loop, continually trying to write to the files (with icons flicking back and forth between the down arrow and the 2-way arrow).

Crazy!

I'll be buying the upgrade to Lightroom 2 soon... I'll see if the bug's still there in the new version!
 
I kind of fixed the problem in a slightly destructive way. :)

Knowing that all the metadata was in fact stored in the files and it was just the metadata icon that was bugged (thanks for finding this, Brad!), I applied a trick from Victoria (thanks, Victoria!) that she used to get rid of 'Error Files'. I deleted one of the problematic files from Lightroom, then imported it again. Bingo! Saved perfectly, icon gone, and all metadata still intact!

The only problem here is that it wiped the editing history for the file. So before I did the rest of the images, I stepped back into the history of each (to the original import, or somewhere I didn't mind calling the new 'unedited' version) and made a slight change to lock that new version's history. I then saved this new metadata, deleted from Lightroom, and re-imported.

In case anyone has ideas on why the bug exists in the first place, I've left one image untouched which can be used as a test.

Thanks again for all the help!

Craig.
 
Oh that's great Craig, nice work!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top