LR 3 beta - very first impressions

Status
Not open for further replies.

LJR69

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2009
Messages
82
Location
UK
So I've downloaded LR 3 and will use it alongside my 'live' LR 2.5 until it's released just to get a feel for it. I like the new import feature straight way. Much more flexibility and I like the look of it too. I of course love the Watermark feature that many have wanted for a good while now too.

One thing I'm a bit disappointed with is that it still appears you can't use Stacks in categories. I really hoped that would make it into this release.

Couple of other things I've noticed really quickly is the additional slider for noise reduction (Edge Detail) and a much improved Vignetting effect with a 'style' feature that appears to be a drop down list (although it seems greyed out on mine and defaulted to "Highlight Priority"), a contrast slider, and a sub-section for Grain (Amount, Size, and Roughness), which incidentally I'm v. happy about.

Finally there's a Publish Services section in the Library Module which currently has two services listed - Hard Drive and Flickr. I'm guessing this will be part of the new SDK so that people can add to those services and could be a real neat feature.
 
Thanks Victoria, should I bombard Adobe with another request for it?
 
Where I work, our hospital was a beta site for a new software program. Personally, I found beta to be too frustrating ( too many bugs) for me. I will sit on the side lines and let you guys be the guinea pigs.

Bob- the slide shooter at heart
 
My first impressions are really favorable. I think the speed increase is really fantastic when it comes to rendering the images is great and I like the new import dialog box - for the most part. I found it incredibly slow when I wanted to "add" images that are on a hard drive. It took quite a bit of time for it to go through all of my drives just to give me a list of folders. I'm hoping this will change, otherwise adding images will be a step backwards (at least for me)
 
I do like the beta version as well, the brushes seem to work much better than before, although I still think the sharpening brush is ineffectual. I must admit to being disappointed with no print preview as yet?!

Peter.
 
Thanks for the slide show tip, Victoria!

I've now tried LR3 Beta on a 2.53GHz MacBook Pro under both OS X SL and Windows 7. I must say it is noticeably faster in the 64-bit Windows 7 version (not that it's slow by any means under OS X). I love it! Given my printing issues with SL, I'm seriously considering switching to the Win 7 partition as my main workspace!
 
Bob, Lr3b can co-exist with Lr2.5. I'd just create a separate photo directory with some test photos in it, so you don't inadvertenly edit some of your 'real' 2.5 pictures with 3.'.

The program is remarkably bug free, if a teensy bit slow at times.
 
Two things did not seem to work Synchronise library, started the process but never completes. Also when I export a picture to a Nik plug-in there is an error message, but the application still opens okay with the photo intact.

Peter.
 
Trying out the new Lightroom 3 Beta... really cleans up Canon 5'D noise and banding pattern. The below image @ ISO 4'' (1'% crop of image) was under-exposed by about 1.85 stops due to flash not recycling in time. Settings are identical in both apps:


LR2:
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2576/4'46698431_c9c1c'2'3'_o.png

LR3beta:

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2692/4'47442752_636d8e7'9b_o.png

Also notice ceiling tiles and hair on left side of frame sharpens up nicely with more detail using LR3Beta... dang I'm impressed!
 
Are you guys having fun yet? I surely am.

The new algorithms are exciting. Dare I say that the difference between versions for me is like back in the day when I had Canon's RAW software and first tried RawShooter? I couldn't buy RS fast enough I was so enchanted with the clarity and the vibrant images. This is the same sort of thing. It's night and day between the two versions.

Puzzling out the Publish deal ....... installed the upload to FTP SDK and that works but thinking that publish might be the place that this should go. Any ideas anyone?

I note that some are disappointed with the lack of this or that and the speed. It's a Beta. Stuff isn't done. Read the readme.

It's nice to stop being mad at Adobe for their horrible customer service and concentrate on the terrific software. I was impressed with the initial Lr project and the endless public consultation. I'm glad to see that the spirit is still there.

So let's be positive folks. We have a terrific new application to work on.
 
Publish is still a work in progress, so someone will probably do a FTP publish plugin once the SDK's available.
 
>The new algorithms are exciting.

Heck Yes!

What's "Publish"?
 
Publish is for synchronised photo sharing - for example, you make a collection in Publish, link it to Flickr, and when you edit the photos in LR, they get updated on Flickr too.
 
... and for maintaining a synchronised set of rendered TIF/PSD/JPEG images on your hard drive.
 
Publish to hard drive is fantastic! I've always exported all of my favourite photos to smaller jpegs so I can have them running as a screensaver on my tv. Now I can simply drag them to the "Publish to harddrive", and always keep the jpeg-folder synchronized.
 
Been playing for a couple of hours now with LR3. The new Import dialogue and the Publish facility are nice. The quality of the image adjustments does seem to have improved, I especially like the new sharpening. The overall interface is almost unchanged and that has always been the worst aspect of LR for me so that has been a bit disappointing for me personally.

-- Mouse scrolling in the filmstrip is broken too, but it could be just that it's Beta :)
 
If there has been a ground up re-build of the processing pipeline, it's a shame that they could not figure out a way to make the images in library look the same as develop. It seems even more stark in difference in this beta. Anyone else notice?
 
my two cents:
it seems to me that now in the Develop module the effect of the Sharpening is visible even when the photo is fitted to the screen, not only when showed at 1:1
this is a great improvement, there is no more need to go to the Grid view, zoom at 1:1, and then back to Fit, to see the global effect of the sharpening...
 
[quote author=Braders link=topic=8159.msg55923#msg55923 date=12568'5453]
If there has been a ground up re-build of the processing pipeline, it's a shame that they could not figure out a way to make the images in library look the same as develop. It seems even more stark in difference in this beta. Anyone else notice?
[/quote]
More work to do on that one yet
 
another observation:
now the sliders of the Adjustment Brush behave in the same way of the others,
that is can be easily moved by pressing (shift +) arrow up/down

the "old" 2.X style just drive me crazy...
 
[quote author=Victoria Bampton link=topic=8159.msg55929#msg55929 date=1256818991]
[quote author=Braders link=topic=8159.msg55923#msg55923 date=12568'5453]
If there has been a ground up re-build of the processing pipeline, it's a shame that they could not figure out a way to make the images in library look the same as develop. It seems even more stark in difference in this beta. Anyone else notice?
[/quote]
More work to do on that one yet
[/quote]

as in...during this beta or don't hold my breath?!

i agree with the sharpening as well. At normal screen view in develop, sharpening is well apparent and, when moving to library the image softens up again.
 
[quote author=Braders link=topic=8159.msg55973#msg55973 date=1256846741]
as in...during this beta or don't hold my breath?!
[/quote]
As in the beta isn't feature complete.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top