Import color terrible with Canon Rebel XT

  • Thread starter Thread starter andyj
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

andyj

Guest
I have a Canon Rebel XT. I've been shooting in RAW and JPG with the same problem: the color when I import to LR is extremely yellow. I bought LR v1.1 and when I saw the color, I upgraded to v1.3, which claims to have the proper interpretor for my camera. E.g. I took a photo of a delicate pink flower. It looks fine downloaded with my Canon software. When imported to LR, the flower was a strong yellow. I messed with the color changes and the camera calibration. I could not get close and when I moved the bars too much, the image started to blotch. I printed the yellow image from LR and although not an excellent print, the flower was pink!

Thanks.
 
Hi Andy,

I own a Canon 35'D (same as your XT) but haven't experienced anything of this nature. I have used Lightroom since the Beta versions without problems. The 1.3 release added support for the EOS 1Ds Mark III and PowerShot G9 Canon models, with your XT being supported in the Beta version and 1.'.

Software programs can handle colours differently but not to this extreme, for example I always found that Canon software reproduced skin tones more faithfully than Camera Raw.

A couple of questions:

Do you see this problem when viewing images on screen or when printing or both?

What color space do you have your XT set for?
 
What color space do you have your XT set for?
This last should not matter one iota, is shooting RAW. It has none. LR always shows in its own ProPhotoRGB special until you specify something else for an Export, and it is only that export that will show the something else.

Don
 
Reply

The problem occurs with the viewing. When I printed it was OK. I apparently was using sRGB, but it sounds like that does not matter.

Thanks, Andy
 
Check you Monitor profile. LR passes images to the screen differently than other programs. You may have a corrupt profile. Easy to check by switching to another an re-viewing in L.

Don
 
same camera

I have the same camera, shoot RAW, process in RGBPro in Lr and Ps, print on a Canon Pro9''', and don't see any odd colour shifts anywhere.

I would agree with Don R - your monitor might be in need of a tweak. If you don't have a profiled monitor I'm afraid it's time to dig into your pocket and come up with the last $25' for a Spyder calibration system or something equally useful.

Truly, it's close to a waste of time to bother with manipulating colour unless your monitor is calibrated. I resisted. I'm glad I came to my senses.

I'm not assuming here that your monitor is not calibrated. If it is, then there might actually be something wrong with it.
 
Color Profiles

Thanks for your input. I have a couple of questions because I'm not high tech.

The color is fine when I use the Canon download software. It is only a problem in LR. Can a profile be corrupted in one program and work for another?

If my profile is corrupted, where do I find a new one?

I have not calibrated my monitor with any system and that sounds like a good idea, but I still come back to my first question.

I appreciate the help. Andy
 
YEs, even though it appears as only a problem in LR, your Monitor Profile can be corrupt. LR does things differently than other Apps. 99% of the time with these exact symptoms, this has been the correct diagnosis to the incredulity of the user.

On a PC you can test it just by switching the profile from the canned one for your monitor to one like sRGB (not a recommended one to continue to use, better to do the software (hardware if you have it) calibration), but it will let you now that in fact ths is your problem.

There are any number of threads on this in the UtoU LR forum. Searches there on Magenta/blue/yellow/green will bring them up, and I have always provided the same advice.

Don
 
Color Profiles

I switched the color profile to AdobeRGB1998. This solved the problem. My PC was using my monitor's profile.

Don, you mentioned that the sRGB profile was not best to use on a continued basis and I should calibrate my monitor. I assume this is the same answer for AdobeRGB1998. I also assume the calibration hardware provides a customized color profile that is turned on in the same manner.

Thanks again for all the help. Andy
 
You are welcome. I have had only one case where this actually failed to be the answer this particular color problem.

Don
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top