How to integrate processed NEF files into LR

  • Thread starter Thread starter marypencheff
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

marypencheff

Guest
I have been shooting raw nef files for 5 years and have been processing in Nikon Capture. I have archived my fine art, web images and important commercial jobs as processed raw files along with their jpegs/tiffs onto an external drive and also in a couple of lkey folders on my second internal harddrive. They are very well organized in sub-folders and I access and work with them on a regular basis. I also add images to my web image folders all the time because I am always updating my site. I add them to the folder with that subject matter so I stay organized. How can I integrate this huge archive into my LR2 workflow? It won't read the adjustments I've made to the raw files right? You can see my dilemma.
Do I need to import everything into LR and then start over with the raw files?
Is there a workflow that would make this feasible ? If so a detailed description would be appreciated. Would I be better off just keeping my Nikon software on the computer and using it for all my archives to this point.
I want to purchase LR today but am really worried this could be a nightmare.
 
One way to integrate these photos into Lightroom is to first convert them into .tif files, thereby preserving your edits, and then importing them into Lightroom. Only you can judge if the effort to convert them into .tifs and having all these photos in Lightroom is worth it.

You might want to try downloading the 3' day trial version of Lightroom first, rather than making the purchase immediately. This will allow you to get some feel of the effort, and some feel of the value.
 
Thanks for your response

I have been shooting raw nef files for 5 years and have been processing in Nikon Capture. I have archived my fine art, web images and important commercial jobs as processed raw files along with their jpegs/tiffs onto an external drive and also in a couple of lkey folders on my second internal harddrive. They are very well organized in sub-folders and I access and work with them on a regular basis. I also add images to my web image folders all the time because I am always updating my site. I add them to the folder with that subject matter so I stay organized. How can I integrate this huge archive into my LR2 workflow? It won't read the adjustments I've made to the raw files right? You can see my dilemma.
Do I need to import everything into LR and then start over with the raw files?
Is there a workflow that would make this feasible ? If so a detailed description would be appreciated. Would I be better off just keeping my Nikon software on the computer and using it for all my archives to this point.
I want to purchase LR today but am really worried this could be a nightmare.

About the workflow part. any suggestions?
 
About the workflow part. any suggestions?

I think you would be best to make duplicates/copies of the files (starting with a small test selection) and importing them with a preset that applies a profile that suits you and other develop settings, maybe just autotone.
See how you go and work from there. As always there is more work to be done to begin with but the reward of a more streamlined workflow does happen!

Welcome aboard as well !! To help us help you could you please take a moment to fill in your signature in the "userCP' that is found in the nav-bar at the top left of the page - thanks.
 
Hi Mary, welcome to the forum!

Bear in mind that you don't have to jump in one go. You can leave the Nikon software on your computer, and continue managing your existing photos as you currently do. Start on any new images on Lightroom, and once you've got a comfortable workflow sorted out, then consider starting to integrate your existing archive.

As far as your existing folder structure goes, Lightroom can use that same structure. It doesn't have to reorganize your files - you can choose 'Add to catalog at existing location' and it'll just reference them where they currently sit.
 
I'm using both Lightroom and Capture NX2 as I find the results I get from NX2 for high ISO images from my D2'' to be much better than LR. I've all NEFs in a catalog and use "Show in Explorer" to locate a NEF file to edit in NX2. In NX2 I save the NEF file and then use "Open with" to open the file again in LR (I do add a "-Edit" to the resulting filename).
 
Thanks!

Thank you both Halfje and Victoria. Great idea Victoria. Halfje when you open your edited raw files in LR2 do your edits stick in LR or is your nef file in its original state before processing? Also why do you need to use explorer to open them in LR won't Nikon view or Capture NX2 allow that?
 
It'll be the unedited state Mary - LR won't know what to do with your Nikon View adjustments.
 
Thank you both Halfje and Victoria. Great idea Victoria. Halfje when you open your edited raw files in LR2 do your edits stick in LR or is your nef file in its original state before processing? Also why do you need to use explorer to open them in LR won't Nikon view or Capture NX2 allow that?

As Victoria said the changes made by NX2 are not visible in Lightroom and that is the reason why you have to create a TIFF file from NX2 that is imported into Lightroom. Just specify that you want to use Lightroom as external editor in NX2 and the Lightroom import dialog is shown when you do "Open with" from NX2.

You can use NX2 from within Lightroom but this will force Lightroom to create an intermediate TIFF file that is passed to NX2 instead of the NEF file. By using the explorer I bypass the intermediate TIFF file.
 
As Victoria said the changes made by NX2 are not visible in Lightroom and that is the reason why you have to create a TIFF file from NX2 that is imported into Lightroom. Just specify that you want to use Lightroom as external editor in NX2 and the Lightroom import dialog is shown when you do "Open with" from NX2.

You can use NX2 from within Lightroom but this will force Lightroom to create an intermediate TIFF file that is passed to NX2 instead of the NEF file. By using the explorer I bypass the intermediate TIFF file.

Ahhh, Thanks Kees.
 
Hi,

Interesting thread and I am very grateful for it. I have just joined the forum and this is the precise topic I was looking for information on.

I have considered using Nikon's Capture NX2 for processing my NEF files, I do however find the ergonomics of NX2 a little irritating and cumbersome.

The combination of LR2 and CS4 suit me very well, it makes routine workflow and management very simple and very fast.

The only concern I have is that NX2 does process a NEF file more effectively in terms of colour accuracy and reproduction, this is where the adobe labs camera profiles have really helped me out.

http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/DNG_Profiles

It's no miracle cure and certainly not a complete substitute for NX2's more accurate processing, but if you prefer the handling of LR2 then the above camera profiles are invaluable.

I do hope that in the not too distant future, NEF files can be read as thoroughly by Lightroom as apparent with NX2.

I remain hopeful and optimistic. :cheesy:

In the meantime of there are any tips or tricks, or advice and guidances, I'd be grateful to hear them.

KR.

Tomas
 
Welcome Tyke!!.........:cheesy:
 
ACD See software manages to view Nikon NEF files _WITH_ all the edits applied in NX2 absolutely perfectly - you cannot tell the difference between viewing a NEF in NX2 compared with viewing it in ACDSee - and it does so almost instantaneously, and it sells for about $7' so I can't see why Adobe cant get it right to do the same.
 
Hi zamlaurie, welcome to the forum!

Other software that appears to 'get it right' is either showing the embedded preview or is using the manufacturer's SDK to process the raw data.

Adobe could have done the same, but then their processing tools would also have been limited to the ones the manufacturer provided - you couldn't have local adjustments, or lens corrections, or anything else like that.

So at the end of the day, you make a choice of which is most important for you.
 
[quote author=zamlaurie link=topic=5662.msg71787#msg71787 date=1281296212]
ACD See software manages to view Nikon NEF files _WITH_ all the edits applied in NX2 absolutely perfectly - you cannot tell the difference between viewing a NEF in NX2 compared with viewing it in ACDSee - and it does so almost instantaneously, and it sells for about $7' so I can't see why Adobe cant get it right to do the same.
[/quote]

Another view.

ACD See is providing you with software that matches the same rendition for $7' as the software provided for free by your camera manufacturer.

Adobe is offering you software that provides you with an alternative rendition, which they believe has superior quality and tools for creativity that is not provided by your camera manufacturer.

Have a look at the different options available and make the choice of the one that provides the output that pleases you most.

Matching the output of you camera manufacturers taste may not be the correct or best choice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top