Kevin, I did very little post processing pre-LR, and as a result I have a huge collection of images from past years.
I am Importing the images from their current locations since my file structure has seemed to stand the test of time, but what I am finding is that the sorting and rating in LR is making it easy for me to get through even a large folder of images pretty quickly.
I learned a while ago, that the best way for me to cull my images is to do a first run immediately following a shoot, and then wait a week or so to do the second wave of culling because the excitement of the shoot has faded and I have less emotional attachment to images.
I use my normal work flow which is a good at extracting the best of the best.
The combination of these two techniques, my workflow and waiting some time before the second cull, result in my dumping a load of images I thought I needed to keep for some reason...by product...recapturing a large amount of drive space!!