Different colors in Photoshop and Lightroom

[paul2004]

I've got a calibrated monitor using "eyeone" hardware and software. color spaces in both LR and PS-2 are ProPhoto RGB. when i send file from LR to PS-2, make a minor edit (fixing "spots") then come back to LR, the photo (now a TIFF-edit) is washed out and in fact, the White Balance controls are changed in LR Develop mode...not able to set temperature like with the original RAW file in LR, and all the other settings are changed from the original RAW file LR settings. when i toggle between the two in LR develop mode, the develop controls are fine in the LR original version, but when i look at the stacked and edited TIFF or PSD, still in LR, the image is way off and the controls have been changed.

just now tested to see if the same issue occurs when i send my original RAW file from LR to a different application (in this case LightZone) just to do some "spot" removal...no other edits. when it comes back into LR, the same issue occurs as in PS-2...in other words, photo is blown out, develop settings are changed, etc.

Any suggestions?

paul

 

[DonRicklin]

I asked pertinent questions to get to the bottom of this on the User to User Forum where you have posted the thread Different colors in Photoshop and Lightroom.

Jao's post is a valid point on this issue.



Meanwhile, would you please fill in your signature with the relevant System and Gear info.

Don
Don

 

[paul2004]

thanks for the info and suggestions. Jao's solution was right on! many thanks to both of you!

paul