Croping Grid Overlay

Status
Not open for further replies.

billcarter393

New Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2008
Messages
5
Croping would much more productive in LR2 if there was an option to add various croping format overlays. For example, when croping an 8x1', overlay a 4x6 grid or when croping a 4x6, overlay a 8x1' grid. This would be very help when preparing an image for sale on a website and your buyer will only the option to crop 8x1' or 4x6 if your uploaded image is properly formatted.
 
Welcome to the forums Bill!

Not sure to understand exactly what you mean without an illustration but there are two main helpers for cropping in Lightroom. When the crop tool is activated, you can change the overlay design by pressing the "O" key. Successive uses of the "O" key will show different overlays in turn. The other is a list of common cropping ratios plus the five last custom ones in the right panel. Hit the up/down arrows beside the ratio. You can lock the ratio with the "Padlock" closed. Hint: When you want to apply to a new photo the very same cropping ratio that you previously used, just press "S" with the crop tool activated.
 
I run into the exact same problem with my print fulfillment website. I know Lee Jay and I have made the feature request several times each; Bill, please join us, the more the merrier.

Optional reading:
For those interested, a little background. Most of my event photos are purchased and processed through a third party's website. I generally offer 4 or 5 of the US standard enlargement sizes for purchase. We photographers all know that an 8*1' crop from a 4*6 original will chop the long-axis significantly, but only about 5% of my customers can figure that out on their own. While the website offers a custom crop feature, very few understand it or use it correctly. It would literally quadruple the effort, with very little return on investment, for me to upload custom crops for the various standard aspect ratios. So, I compromise with trying to shoot and upload standard 4*6s, that have the property of being 'safe' to default center-crop at the other standard ratios. After several tens of thousands, I can more or less do this 'by eye', but a custom cropping template showing these relationships, would be helpful.
 
Brad Snyder;36'77 said:
I run into the exact same problem with my print fulfillment website. I know Lee Jay and I have made the feature request several times each; Bill, please join us, the more the merrier.

Optional reading:
For those interested, a little background. Most of my event photos are purchased and processed through a third party's website. I generally offer 4 or 5 of the US standard enlargement sizes for purchase. We photographers all know that an 8*1' crop from a 4*6 original will chop the long-axis significantly, but only about 5% of my customers can figure that out on their own. While the website offers a custom crop feature, very few understand it or use it correctly. It would literally quadruple the effort, with very little return on investment, for me to upload custom crops for the various standard aspect ratios. So, I compromise with trying to shoot and upload standard 4*6s, that have the property of being 'safe' to default center-crop at the other standard ratios. After several tens of thousands, I can more or less do this 'by eye', but a custom cropping template showing these relationships, would be helpful.
Brad, You are right on target. You expressed the problem much better than I did.

Thanks,
Bill
 
Mark Sirota;36'49 said:
I think he wants another cropping overlay, one that shows a 4x5 rectangle within the 2x3 rectangle, and vice-versa.

Others have asked for that too. File a feature request and add your voice.
Mark, that's exactly what I'm looking for. It would help those of us who sell photos on third party website sites.

Thanks,
Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top