Colorspace Issue LR / CS2 / DNG

  • Thread starter Thread starter danigoes4lr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

danigoes4lr

Guest
I'm thinking of converting raw files (Nikon D2'') to DNG before burning on DVD for my customers. So I played around whith it a bit. I Converted some (unedited) raw files to DNG and compared the colors in:
  • LR
  • CS2, opened out of LR
  • CS2, opened via file..open
Color settings:
  • Camera: shot with Adobe RGB 1998 or sRGB
  • LR: (Ctrl+U): Adobe RGB 1998
  • CS2 (edit..color settings...): Adobe RGB 1998
Colors and brightness are the same in LR and in CS2 when opened via LR. But they look very different when opened in CS2 via file..open. I tried as well with sRGB (seetings ind LR and CS2) and I tried with an image shot with sRGB. Result remains the same: different colors.

Any hints or ideas?

thx
Daniel
 
The latest version that can be used by CS2 is ACR 3.7.
Lightroom version 1.4.1 uses the ACR 4.4.1 engine.
There are some settings in LR/ACR 4.4.1 which are not available in ACR 3.7 such as clarity, vibrance and some other presets that you could have applied that ACR 3.7 cannot apply.
 
Thanks Denis.

I did not apply any manual settings.

I don't understand the difference between open a DNG from the context menue (right click on the image) and open it directly in CS2 via file..open. I mean it is still CS2, isn't it?
 
Thanks Denis.

I did not apply any manual settings.

I don't understand the difference between open a DNG from the context menue (right click on the image) and open it directly in CS2 via file..open. I mean it is still CS2, isn't it?

If its a raw file it opens in ACR with the camera defaults then is sent to PS.
PS CS2 cannot open raw files without the ACR Plugin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top