Hi David, thank you for sharing. I think there are some subtleties on this subject that I'd like to point out:
As I am in the market for a new Macbook I am exploring the benefits of having more RAM so I went looking for information on this subject. On this very forum I found
this topic which mentioned
https://youtu.be/5ESZDAeZ9vo. After watching this video I conclude that for specific use cases it seems quite prudent actually to keep on the ample RAM side of things. I believe you did very well choosing 32GB over 16GB.
The author of the video even mentions large file handling such as stitching pano's or editing ultra res files (up to many gigabytes for one file) as an area of photo editing that can benefit not only from more RAM but also
faster RAM-to-CPU/GPU bandwith with up to 400GB/s as featured by the M1 Max line. Photo editors that perform these tasks will know who they are, I am not one of them.
There is, however, another consideration:
maximum life span. When I purchased my current Late 2013 MacBook Pro I made two bad (insufficient) configuration choices: 512GB SSD and 16GB RAM. I am still using this machine to date because it provides sufficient performance for all but one area of computing: photo (and video) editing. Therefore I am about to replace a machine that is still working 100% fine, which I consider (1) a waste of earthly resources and (2) budget.
So in order to maximise the life span of my next macbook pro I want to tweak the configuration so that no component other than the CPU/GPU will eventually cause it to retire. In that respect I believe I should get at least:
- at least 1TB SSD, maybe 2TB
- All the internal bandwith I can get -> M1 Max
- at least 32GB of RAM, I'll probably get 64GB just to be sure
Yes this will become a costly purchase, but considering the life cycle costing aspect I believe the added investment for SSD, M1 Max and RAM will pay off eventually. Having used my current macbook pro for over 8 years, I know I have regretted the SSD size after about a couple of months and the RAM after a couple of years. Therefore, the added benefit of tweaking these components is that I will have a happier use experience even right from the start.
YMMV.