adding keywords to multiple images at same time

  • Thread starter Thread starter wrightm
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wrightm

Guest
Hello,
I am in the process of keywording a large number of images. If I select 4 images and enter one keywork in, press enter, usually this keyword is applied to all 4 images.
But now all of a sudden, it will only apply the keyword to the one image. Not sure what just changed, but what am I don't wrong? How come it is not applying to all?
thanks,
Matt
 
ahhh..thanks....that may be why...I was keywording in grid mode then switched to enlarge to keyword more closely. You cannot keyword multiple images when in enlarge mode then?
thanks,
M
 
That's right. (And the Lightroom term is loupe, not enlarge).

Given the frequent confusion about this, someone should probably submit a feature request for AutoSync-like behavior in Library.
 
I've never been quite clear about Adobe's logic in making selection in the film strip or in the secondary grid different from selection in the primary grid.

I know it has been stated that this is 'by design' rather than a bug, but it does seem to be extremely counter-inuitive and confusing, especially for a new user.

There's no indication anywhere that you should expect a different behaviour in these places, which appear and feel so very similar; this is just something that you have to learn by experience.

I can't see any benefit in not harmonising the seletion functionality across the three, and I can see advantages in so doing; I do occasionally have to revert from a loupe view to grid, simply to enable me to make a multiple selection, when I would prefer to do this on one of the other two thumbnail displays. It is also why I keep the primary LR window on my second monitor, which is a lower quality, and put the secondary window on my 'quality' monitor. I would prefer to do detailed work in the primary window, which is updated instantly and contains all the tools and previews, on the Hi-Q monitor and use the secondary display for the grid in the secondary window. But I can't because with that config I can't multiple select in the available grid.

If there is consensus that this is a problem I will file a request to Adobe. If anyone can explain Adobe's justification, or give a compelling reason why the present functionality is preferrable, I won't.

Best regards

Patrick Cunningham
 
Patrick, there is no difference where you make the selection.

The difference is where you perform an action.

If you had multiple images selected in the filmstrip and were in Loupe view, and the filmstrip is hidden, and you change the rating to 4 stars, would you expect that to affect all selected images?

(I still support an AutoSync-like switch for Library... Just trying to explain the current design.)
 
This feature tripped me up a number of times before I worked out what was going on. I was trying to apply key words to multiple images only to find out "later" that they were not applied. On the other hand I have also been tripped up the otherway as well when I was in grid mode but forgot I had multiple images selected and applied changes to all images. At least I was able to reverse this using the un-edit button.

I have now got used to the way it is and it has become intuitive.
 
I had this problem too, coming from Aperture where you can select in the grid, list or filmstrip without any change in functionality made a lot more sense to me.
 
wrightm;437'2 said:
ahhh..thanks....that may be why...I was keywording in grid mode then switched to enlarge to keyword more closely. You cannot keyword multiple images when in enlarge mode then?

One way to get around this is to drag the thumbnail size slider all the way to one end, that way you will only see one full-sized image even though, technically, you're still in grid mode.

Of course, it makes things a lot harder to switch back and forth between a real grid and the zoomed grid.

Guess it's time to get that second monitor...
 
I had this problem too, coming from Aperture where you can select in the grid, list or filmstrip without any change in functionality made a lot more sense to me.

Just want to clarify: In Lightroom, it doesn't matter where you select. It only matters what your current view is when you apply the change.

You might have made the selection half an hour ago. That's immaterial.
 
Just want to clarify: In Lightroom, it doesn't matter where you select. It only matters what your current view is when you apply the change.

You might have made the selection half an hour ago. That's immaterial.

OK, that does clarify a little - thanks Mark! Looking at it that way helps to make better sense of the functionality. I can also understand the down-side of applying changes to all selected images regardless of what the current view is - it would be easy to forget that you have a number of images selected if you are looking at a loupe view and erroneously apply changes to all.

So if we accept the advisability of keeping the current functionality, then we just need to make it clear to new users somehow. If I remember correctly it is already in Victoria's Ten Commandments!

A useful discussion nonetheless.

Patrick Cunningham
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top